Pixar hasn’t just reinvented animation for the 21st century, they’ve expanded it forward to a space and time where the adult/child line is blurred and the creativity on display is astonishingly rendered. You forget you’re watching a film primarily aimed for kids. You feel like a child again, full of innocence, full of joy, discovering a new world that previously seemed so out of reach. Over the past 20 years, Pixar has given us so much more than 15 timeless movies; they’ve brought us the ability to succumb to a universe full of magic and stories that hit the truest notes possible. It’s hard to imagine a cinematic landscape without Pixar, and the significance they represent cannot be underestimated. Their effect on regular, live-action movies is self-evident. They’ve pushed boundaries and forced other
filmmakers to think beyond the box. Here’s to another 20 great years.
1) WALL-E (2008)
Any Pixar list must begin and end with this masterpiece. The first half hour of WALL-E has scarcely any dialogue and plays like a silent Chaplin movie -– that is if he had ever decided to make a post-apocalyptic movie about a lonely garbage-chewing bot who falls in love with an A.I. named Eve. The second half is more conventional but nevertheless visionary. The future that director Andrew Stanton concocts is that of a torn up world, ravaged by an environmental crisis, where the planet’s citizens have been evacuated to live aboard a space cruiser, with only one last possible chance to rebuild.
2) Up (2009)
I don’t know many people who can come out of this film’s first 10 minutes with a dry eye. In 10 hopelessly romantic and surreal minutes, Pixar gave us the quintessential anatomy of life, love, and death in a simple but heartbreaking montage that might just be the crowning achievement of the studio. Although the rest of the film can’t reach the peak of that montage (and really, which can?), the rest of the film is incredibly great and visually vivid, bursting out with colors. It’s an allegorical film about aging without regret but with dignity.
3) Inside Out (2015)
“Inside Out” opens this week with a flurry of rave reviews and a brilliant marketing campaign that will have you in stitches, but is the movie any good? Yes. It’s damn good. In fact, this is the brainiest, most trippy movie Pixar has made so far. Coming out of the theater, a buddy of mine, who is coincidentally a psychologist, told me the movie should be mandatory viewing for all psych students. How does Pixar come up with such ambitiously ingenious ideas? I’m guessing this is the movie most have not yet seen from my list, so I won’t say much, but just let your brain have a little workout with this golden nugget of a movie.
4) The Incredibles (2004)
While we get relentlessly pummeled by countless superhero movies every single year, it is a breath of fresh air to see the genre work so triumphantly well. Brad Bird has proven his worth in the past, most notably with the criminally underrated animated movie “The Iron Giant”. Bird gives us another visual treat by tackling the superhero genre and coming out with a classic that can stand alongside “The Dark Knight” and “Spider-Man 2”. The action scenes are breathtakingly staged, with Bird’s incredible eye for detail and pacing coming in handy. Unlike many superhero movies, this is one of the rare cases where a sequel would be welcome and well-deserved.
5) Toy Story 3 (2010)
What more can be said about “Toy Story 3”? It was supposed to be the last hurrah. A sequel was just announced recently, but it will be very hard to top this achievement. Tackling adult themes, the movie was the darkest, most vicious of the series, with a villain who could scare you more than any live-action baddie. The stakes were dead real, tackling the loss of innocence and the promotion – or is that a demotion? – to adulthood. Near the end of the movie’s wrenching climax, as our heroes are about to get cooked alive in an oven, you can’t help but think the inevitable could actually happen. Never have I feared for the lives of animated characters more than in this movie.
6) Ratatouille (2007)
A Parisian rat named Remy just wants to become a chef. This could have gone wrong on so many levels, but it didn’t. “Ratatouille” is highly enjoyable, recounting some of the Disney gems from the golden age of animation. When Remy starts cooking up a storm in the Parisian kitchen he has crashed, the moves are like ballet, effortlessly propelling his miniature body all around the kitchen and unequivocally expressing his unadorned passion for cooking. This again shows just how influenced by Chaplin the great animators at Pixar really are.
7) Finding Nemo (2003)
I can think of three times in cinematic history where an actor or actress deserved to get nominated for a voice performance: Robin Williams as the Genie in “Aladdin”, Jeremy Irons as Scar in “The Lion King”, and of course Ellen DeGeneres as Dory in Pixar’s “Finding Nemo”. The work DeGeneres does here is nothing short of brilliant. She uses a playful innocence to counterbalance Albert Brooks’ sombre, more serious tone as Nemo’s father. The lighter optimism of Dory shines through and perfectly complements the astonishing visuals of the coral reef in all its glory.
8) Toy Story 2 (1999)
We had no right to expect a sequel that would be better than the original, but that’s exactly what “Toy Story 2” accomplished. This time around we had a better story, improved animation, and an exhilarating sense of adventure. If the original was riding high off of its landmark CGI, this sequel was trying to perfect the glitches that held the story back a little the first time around. With Indiana Jones styled action, “Toy Story 2” proved there was still room to expand in the Pixar canon, and that these guys were dead serious about blowing us away.
9) Toy Story (1995)
It all started here. The first time I saw “Toy Story” I could scarcely imagine how groundbreaking and important it would become for animation. This movie literally changed the game and practically got rid of all hand drawn animation in Hollywood, which of course is a real shame, because hand drawn is still one of the most beautiful and creative ways to make a movie – just look at any Hayao Miyazaki movie if you don’t believe me. Now almost every single animated movie is CGI and we’ve relied so heavily on it because of how monstrous a success Pixar had with “Toy Story”. The facial expressions, the movements, and the effortless flow that carry characters about was unprecedented. It was goodbye to the classical and welcome to the new age.
10) Monsters Inc. (2000)
There hasn’t been a cuter, more adorable Pixar creation than Boo. The little girl who called Sully “Kitty” just about made the movie for me. The attention to detail given to Boo was simply amazing, encompassing the smallest, most precious details a baby girl can have. Every time she spoke you couldn’t help but just want to hug the screen. Kudos must be given to directors Pete Docter, Lee Unkrich and David Silverman who let this kid run loose and cause chaos at Monsters Inc. Billy Crystal and John Goodman’s voice work and chemistry here is tremendous.
Never seen: Toy Story 2 (!), Cars, Cars 2, A Bug’s Life
11. Monsters University
10. Monsters Inc.
9. Up
8. Brave
7. WALL*E
6. Inside Out
5. Ratatouille
4. Toy Story 3
3. Toy Story
2. The Incredibles
1. Finding Nemo
Wow, talk about a deep list. The first five are masterpieces — the bottom five are “merely” very good films that I would happily watch again.
Glad to see some Brave admirers. I’m in the minority for loving it. Thank you Jordan Ruimy!
I was asked what would have been number 11 through 15. I’m very big on “Brave”, I think it’s the most underrated Pixar. Conventional? Yes. Visually stunning? No doubt about it.
“Cars” is another underrated gem. The sequel is the worst thing they’ve ever done, but the original in 2006 had a great hometown/western vibe to it and Paul Newman’s voicework was just great.
11. Brave
12. Cars
13. A Bug’s Life
14. Monsters University
15. Cars 2
For Me:
Up
Toy Story 2
Toy Story 3
Inside Out
Toy Story
Monsters Inc.
The Incredibles
WALL-E
Monsters University
Finding Nemo
Ratatouille
Cars
Brave
A Bug’s Life
Cars 2
I have always been in the minority regarding Up. I think the much-lauded prologue is positively wonderful, but the following hour and a half can’t match it. Pixar movies are often a little bizarre and fantastic, but function with a rigid internal logic that makes the world seem whole and cohesive – Up, for its part, is too willfully strange and quirky to hold together as much, and ends up feeling extremely slight once you get past the callbacks to the virtuoso first ten minutes. A good movie overall, but not the studio’s best work.
I’ve not seen Inside Out yet, but this is my ranking of the rest:
WALL-E
The Incredibles
Ratatouille
Toy Story 2
Finding Nemo
Toy Story
Toy Story 3
Brave
Up
Monsters Inc.
A Bug’s Life
Cars
Monsters University
Cars 2
There is the obvious 10 and A Bugs Life for me (which seems to be somewhat underappreciated nowadays and is certainly hurt by the Antz similarities, but I’ve always found it holds up quite well over the years on repeat viewings).
Cars is fine for what it is. Brave is by far the most lacklustre I’ve seen (even a train wreck), although I am yet to see the Cars and Monsters sequels, nor Inside Out.
1. Finding Nemo
2. Ratatouille
3. Brave
4. Up
5. Toy Story
6. The Incredibles
7. Monsters Inc.
8. Wall-E
9. Toy Story 2
10. A Bug’sLife
I’m going to divvy up Pixar into tiers, where films within each tier are roughly interchangeable in ranking
WALL-E – one of my five favorite films of all-time, and like in my personal Top 5 greatest animated films (along w/ Grave of the Fireflies, Pinocchio, Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind, and Princess Mononoke)
Finding Nemo, Toy Story 2, The Incredibles, Ratatouille, Toy Story
Up, Toy Story 3, Brave
Monsters Inc., Monsters University, A Bug’s Life
Cars, Cars 2
My ranking
1. Finding Nemo (Sweet, funny and above all about the power of love and conquering your own limits)
2. Toy Story 3 (Clever, Funny, Scary, Moving: Brilliant!)
3. Wall-E (Subtle, Sad, Profund: Brilliant!)
4. Ratatouille
5. Up
6. Toy Story 2
7. Toy Story
8. The Incredibles
9. Monsters Inc
10. A bug’s life
11. Cars
12. Brave
Uff.. hard to rank though. They are all so different and inventive. I think your ranking also changes with time. I remembered I looved TS, The Incredibles and Monsters Inc when I first saw them.
Haven’t seen Cars 2, Monsters U and Inside Out.
@Jordan @Ryan – Yup, no biggies! Just thought it would benefit everyone to point out it could use a second look. Everyone’s work needs to be edited from time to time, especially when being posted in a rush. As long as the content is there!
With that said, my list (assuming you don’t count Toy Story as one trilogy):
1. Wall-E (A+)
2. Toy Story 2 (A+)
3. Toy Story 3 (A+)
4. Ratatouille (A)
5. Finding Nemo (A)
6. The Incredibles (A)
7. Toy Story (A)
8. Monsters, Inc. (A-)
9. Up (A-)
10. Brave (B+)
11. A Bug’s Life (B+)
12. Cars (B)
13. Monsters University (B)
14. Cars 2 (B-)
Not a single bad film… not even Cars 2, which is purely mediocre.
Haven’t seen Inside Out yet, but I’m looking forward to it even more now. I agree with the ranking of all the other films on this list.
WALL-e is my number 1 if you count the Toy Story films separately. If you count them as one trilogy, Toy Story is the greatest thing they’ve done, with WALL-e a close second. I count them as a trilogy together, and therefore my list looks like this:
1. The TOY STORY trilogy
2. WALL-E
3. FINDING NEMO
4. INSIDE OUT
5. UP
6. RATATOUILLE
7. THE INCREDIBLES
8. MONSTERS INC.
9. A BUG’S LIFE
10. BRAVE
11. CARS
12. MONSTERS UNIVERSITY
13. CARS 2
Wall-E my number 1 too, just remarkable. Good stuff Jordan, again.
take a look at the number of typos in there.
I went back and found a half dozen blips, nothing very significant. I’ll admit I scanned this pretty quickly because I had to be someplace and we wanted Jordan’s work online right away.
Part of my job is to smooth out any rough spots. Thanks for the suggestion to patch a few keystrokes, Ricky.
OMG!! Hahahaha!! I completely forgot that Frozen isn’t a Pixar. That’s right, it’s a Disney movie. Silly me. 🙂
Frozen is not a Pixar movie.
Jordan, it’s pretty cool of you to rank these. Thanks for that. I have to laugh that you left off both Cars movies and Brave and Frozen. Thank you for that!
Anyway, I’ve only seen 7 Pixar movies so far, and here’s how I rank them:
1. The Incredibles – 2004
2. Toy Story – 1995
3. Monsters, Inc. – 2001
4. Finding Nemo – 2003
5. Toy Story 3 – 2010
6. Toy Story 2 – 1999
7. WALL-E – 2008
Pretty great: RATATOUILLE, THE INCREDIBLES, TOY STORY
Pretty good: TOY STORY 2; MONSTERS, INC
That’s it for me. Pixar rarely gets my juices going. (Ew to myself)
Seeing INSIDE OUT sometime this weekend.
1. Ratatouille
2. Toy Story
3. Inside Out (I literally just got back from it. It really is that good. I hope as many people as possible check it out this weekend.)
4. Toy Story 3
5. WALL-E
6. Finding Nemo
7. Toy Story 2
8. Up
9. The Incredibles
10. A Bug’s Life
I haven’t seen Inside Out yet (I’m sure I’ll be over the moon for in in a few days) but depending on the day of the week any f the top 9 could have the #1 spot. My top spot, over the last several months alone, has gone to Toy Story 1, Toy Story 3, Wall-E, Up, Ratatouille, and Finding Nemo. Gun to my head I would probably say Wall-E for the first half alone.
Also, in addition to Williams, DeGeneres and Irons I would also say Eddie Murphy for Shrek and Scarlett Johansson for Her were Oscar worthy for their vocals. Johansson’s work, in a way, is the most accomplished because we only got her voice and only her voice. Everybody else had top tier animated characters that worked off the performances.
I think the first acts of both WALL-E and Up! are short-film masterpieces within great but far from perfect feature films. Just like the first act of Saving Private Ryan or the first and the fourth parts of Paisan, if we take the discussion to live-action films. Before watching Inside Out, my Pixar top 10 films, shorts included, is:
1. Toy Story 3
2. Toy Story
3. Geri’s Game
4. Monsters, Inc.
5. Finding Nemo
6. Toy Story 2
7. Up!
8. For the Birds
9. WALL-E
10. The Incredibles
Pixar (by this day) has released “only” 15 movies. Why not rank all of them? In my book “Up” will be always number one (“Wall-E” being a close second). The way this movie shows what love is, what commitment is, how it emphasizes the importance of passing on knowledge to youg generations, but also of learning form the young generation. The importance of sticking to your rules, but also learning to let go of things that are wighing you down. The most humane, touching and beautiful of all of them. Pixar has made a lot of brilliant films, a couple of masterpieces, but this one truly stands out.
(Haven’t seen “Inside Out” yet, but just by looking at the response the movie is getting, I might have to change my ranking in the near future. Can’t wait to see it.)
@ Ricky: Hmmm that’s strange. Always very strict about getting the best possible quality in my writing and editing out all the typos. Which did you catch? I just re-read it. Thanks!
Love the list and I agree with most of it, especially Wall-E at #1 (I’m always on the fence with which I prefer between Toy Stories 1 and 2 as well), but you should take a look at the number of typos in there. Not to be dickish, but they hold back the writing quite a bit. Should be easy to fix.